top of page

Beyond Points:
10 Ways Credit Unions Can Reward Member Behaviour

October 21 2025 | Authored by: Jasmin Athwal

5 min read

In today’s world, loyalty isn’t just about collecting points, it’s about connection. Credit unions have a unique advantage: their members already believe in community and purpose. But when it comes to engagement, many still rely on transactional rewards (“spend more, earn more”).

 

At Cyder, we believe the next generation of loyalty is behaviour-based: rewarding members for doing things that make them stronger financially, more engaged with their credit union, and more connected to their community.

 

Here are ten rewarding use cases that go far beyond “points for purchases.”

pexels-morriyn-33438898.jpg

1. Reward Account Milestones

From opening an account to completing an online profile, small actions at the start of a member’s journey set the tone for lasting loyalty.

 

Examples:

  • Reward members who complete their digital onboarding steps

  • Offer a welcome bonus for linking external accounts or going paperless

  • Incentivize first direct deposit

Why it works: Early engagement reduces churn and builds familiarity with your ecosystem.

 

2. Incentivize Savings and Financial Wellness

Healthy habits create loyal members. Reward members who consistently grow their savings or hit financial goals.


 

Examples:

  • 500 points for reaching a savings milestone

  • Monthly bonus for maintaining an emergency fund balance

  • “Level-up” badges for financial health improvements (e.g., credit score increases)

Why it works: Encourages responsible behaviour, builds trust, and aligns with the credit union’s mission of member success.

 

3. Encourage On-Time Payments

Financial wellness is a journey, and rewarding responsibility helps members stay on track.


 

Examples:

  • Bonuses for a streak of on-time loan or credit card payments

  • Re-engagement rewards for returning to good standing after a missed payment

Why it works: Lowers delinquency rates and supports members in developing strong financial routines.

 

4. Celebrate Product Bundling

Rewarding members for using multiple products deepens engagement and increases retention.


 

Examples:

  • Extra points for adding a mortgage, insurance, or investment account

  • “Bundle bonuses” after maintaining multiple products for six months

Why it works: Boosts share of wallet while showing members the holistic value of your credit union.

 

5. Shop Local, Earn Local

Community loyalty starts on Main Street. Rewarding purchases at local merchants connects financial wellness with community impact.


 

Examples:

  • Points or cashback for shopping at participating local businesses

  • Double-reward weekends to drive small-business traffic

  • Bonus rewards for supporting minority-owned or sustainable merchants

Why it works: Strengthens your brand’s community roots while helping members see tangible local impact.

6. Reward Referrals and Advocacy

Word-of-mouth is powerful and authentic. Turn your members into advocates.


 

Examples:

  • Points for every successful referral

  • Rewards for leaving a review or completing a member survey

  • Gamified “top referrer” leaderboards

Why it works: Drives organic growth and gives loyal members a reason to share their positive experiences.

 

7. Recognize Longevity and Retention

Loyalty is built over time, so celebrate it.


 

Examples:

Anniversary rewards (e.g., 1 year, 5 years, 10 years of membership)

“Stay bonuses” for renewing loans or term deposits

Why it works: Reinforces belonging and reminds members their loyalty is valued.

 

8. Reward Community and Philanthropy

Credit unions have always stood for community. Why not reward it, too?


 

Examples:

  • Points for donating to local charities or participating in CU-sponsored drives

  • Rewards for volunteering hours logged

  • Double points on Giving Tuesday

Why it works: Aligns with values-driven members who want their money and actions to make a difference.

 

9. Incentivize Education and Financial Literacy

An informed member is an empowered one.


 

Examples:

  • Points for completing online financial education modules

  • Rewards for attending workshops or webinars

  • Badges for completing a “Money 101” challenge

Why it works: Builds stronger, more confident members while positioning your CU as a trusted guide.

 

10. Reward Digital Engagement

Loyalty doesn’t only live at the branch.


 

Examples:

  • Points for using the mobile app, setting alerts, or enrolling in e-statements

  • Streaks for regular log-ins or feature use

  • Rewards for trying new tools like budgeting dashboards or goal trackers

Why it works: Increases digital adoption and reduces service costs while keeping members connected.

Putting It All Together: Designing a Smart Rewards Mix

Not every credit union needs to reward every behaviour. The key is to connect rewards to your strategy, whether that’s product growth, retention, or community engagement.

 

Here’s a simple framework to guide your design:

  • Define your goal: What behaviour are you trying to influence?

  • Pick 3–5 priority behaviours to reward first.

  • Choose meaningful rewards (cashback, local gift cards, donations, or experiences).

  • Automate and personalize: Use data to trigger rewards in real time.

  • Measure and iterate: Track which actions drive engagement and adjust accordingly.

 

Cyder’s platform makes this process simple, from defining behaviours to delivering personalized, data-driven rewards that reflect your mission.

pexels-muratak-33917277.jpg
pexels-arina-krasnikova-6338493.jpg
pexels-lureofadventure-19013118.jpg

The Future of Credit Union Loyalty

When credit unions reward what matters, saving, supporting local, growing responsibly, they strengthen both their communities and their bottom line.

Behaviour-based loyalty isn’t just a trend. It’s how credit unions can stay relevant, deepen trust, and turn everyday actions into lasting loyalty.

 

Ready to Reward What Matters?

Let’s build your next loyalty program, one that celebrates members for living their values. Learn more at GetCyder.com. 

Looking Ahead

The future of loyalty isn’t just about getting people to spend more. It’s about building relationships that last, and letting your values guide how you grow.

 

Credit unions that embrace enterprise loyalty will stand out. Not because they’re trying to be different for the sake of it, but because they’re grounded in who they are. That’s the kind of loyalty people remember.

Build the right loyalty program with Cyder.

If you're looking to thrive amidst a changing loyalty and rewards landscape, Cyder can help. We encourage you to book a one-on-one demo today with Cyder’s loyalty experts.

July 1, 2025 | Author: Jasmin Athwal

Learn More About Our Loyalty Program 

If you're looking to thrive amidst a changing loyalty and rewards landscape, Cyder can help. We encourage you to book a one-on-one demo today with Cyder’s CU loyalty experts.

bottom of page